::READERS REVIEWS::

Innes at his Best - I believe "Lament for a Maker" is Innes's finest book, towering above all of his other mysteries (and, yes, I have read them all). The story is told, "Moonstone"-like, by a series of narrators - and each peels another layer off the complex and seemingly impossible mystery. The miserly laird of a remote Scottish castle dies in a fall from his tower - but was it suicide? Accident? Murder? Little is at it seems in this marvelous book. And through it, as a theme, runs the powerful poem by the medieval Scottish poet, William Dunbar, "Lament for the Makers," with its repeated and haunting refrain, "Timor mortis conturbat me," the fear of death disturbs me. Into all of this comes Scotland Yard detective John Appleby, to make sense of this rich and deeply disturbing mystery. It is filled with images which will stick in the mind - the crazed laird, prowling with a candle through his own castle, muttering the words of Dunbar to himself; the young lovers facing a terrifying secret; the "daftie" who works at the castle striding through a howling snowstorm to cry murder outside the church, even the castle rats play a significant (and highly unusual) role in this book. All of this is leavened with wit and humor, as one would expect in an Innes novel. If it were possible to award six stars, I would do so. This book should not be missed.

Too much melodrama, too much Scots dialect - This much admired Innes novel is actually one of my least favorite. The story of a mysterious death, in a snow storm, in Scotland, of the Laird of Erchany, is told by several different characters, which I found annoying.
The plot is like something out of a nineteenth century gothic ghost story. The only part I really liked, was a section dealing with adventure in Australia, which comes vividly to life. I own almost all of Innes, and have reread some of them more than ten times. This one only twice.

A Most Remarkable Tale that left me Breathless! - I have never read Michael Innes before, so I was not prepared for this book at all. It is wonderfully complex, and the characterizations are truly masterful. The setting of the book is also noteworthy since it takes place at a remote Scottish castle right at Christmastime. The book does not spare the reader. It will take you on an emotional roller-coaster ride that never ends until the very last page. Innes' portrayal of a a mad Scottish lord is chilling. And Innes' detective John Appleby has to be one of the the most unique in the whole industry. I cannot say enough good things about this book, and about Michael Innes. Whatever you do try to find it and read it, read it, read it. I got my copy from the library. Luckily one library in our wonderful system saw the merits of keeping this very old book.

Nightmare at Erchany - Pulls one solution of the hat, then another and another, and unlike some of the later books, Sir John Appleby himself is far from being the last word on thr truth. Appleby gets some of the clues, but his distance from Scottish culture leaves him at a loss when it comes to contextualization. Sometimes he can't see what's right in front of his face.

To tell you the truth, I got tired of the constantly shifting explanations of what Sybil Guthrie is said to have seen in the tower. Okay, okay, so it's the old Rashomon/Three Coffins story about how even eyewitnesses can be fooled into believing something that isn't true, and that the "evidence of things seen" should really be the last resort when trying to piece together what actually has occurred at a crime scene. For all the credence the several detective figures place on Miss Guthrie's account, I never saw why none of them doubted the essential tenor of what she had to say. Why shouldn't she have been lying her American heart out? She was the heiress, for goodness' sake. She's the one who had more motive than any of them to throw Ranald Guthrie down to the frozen maelstrom at the tower's distant base.

However that's neither here nor there. The eventual explanations for Hardcastle's inquiry about, "Oh hi, are you the doctor?" and for old mad, Ranald Guthrie, the legendary miser who picked the pockets of scarecrows hoping for some forgotten change, now changing his pitch and serving his guests caviar, are both excellently done and you will never guess! Michael Innes is famous for his witty, erudite crime novels but here he has actually come up with a novel that has atmosphere too, some of the dark, spooky John Dickson Carr kind, and some almost human characters about whom you might almost feel something

Speaking of Carr, this novel seems very much like his similarly Scottish slash tower novel THE CASE OF THE CONSTANT SUICIDES. Coincidence? Or were both men working out some kind of internecing Highlands feud, like that of the Guthries and the Lindsays in LAMENT?

"Timor Mortis conturbat me" - Threaded throughout "Lament for a Maker" (1938) is the haunting strain of William Dunbar's (1465-1520?) medieval dirge of that name:

"I that in heill was and gladnèss
Am trublit now with great sickness
And feblit with infirmitie:--

Timor Mortis conturbat me."

A bit of Scots dialect and a little Latin wouldn't hurt in making sense of this Appleby mystery, and it is well worth the effort as "Lament for a Maker" is considered to be one of Michael Innes's best genre novels.

Inspector Appleby doesn't appear on scene at Erchany, Guthrie's castle until the last third of the book. There are five narrators in all, each with his own distinctive voice. There are also several solutions to the murder, and Innes makes each solution seem like the correct one when presented by one of the narrators. I think this is his most rigorous and plausible mystery---well, except for the intrusion of the messenger rats---this author cannot resist a slight touch of the surreal.

The Laird of Erchany, Ranald Guthrie has two outstanding traits: his miserliness, which is causing his castle to fall down around his ears; and his fear of death: he chants "Lament for a Maker" through his rat-infested halls, and the villagers of Kinkeig quite rightly think him mad. He is served by the Hardcastles, a seedy old couple, and Tammas, a brain-damaged boy. Even as Ranald Guthrie might remind you of an evil Prospero, and his niece Christine of Miranda, Tammas will make you think of Caliban.

Two guests are stranded at Erchany on Christmas Eve by a snow storm, and one of them just happens to be the Laird of Erchany's American heir. When Tammas struggles through the snow drifts and into the village of Kinkeig on Christmas morning, the early kirk-goers are interrupted by cries of murder most foul.

Inspector Appleby, a solicitor, a cobbler, a physician, and the Laird of Erchany's unwanted guests must work together to prevent more lives from being destroyed by a plot that seethes in fratricide, incest, and a centuries-old clan feud.